Winchester Shotguns Showdown: A Comparison between the Legendary 1887 and 1897 Models

Introduction

The Winchester Repeating Arms Company, or simply Winchester, is renowned for producing some of the most iconic firearms in American history. Among its vast catalog, two models have earned legendary status: the Winchester Model 1887 and the Model 1897. This article aims to provide an in-depth comparison between these two pump-action shotguns, focusing on their design, features, and historical significance.

Design and Features

Model 1887: The Tube Magazine Shotgun

Introduced in 1885, the Model 1887 was designed by John Browning and features a unique tubular magazine that holds up to six 20-gauge or four 12-gauge rounds. The shotgun’s hammerless design made it a popular choice among hunters and law enforcement officers due to its simplicity and reliability. Its 26-inch barrel provides an adequate length for hunting various game birds, while the pump-action mechanism allows for quick follow-up shots.

Model 1897: The Slide-Action Shotgun

Debuted in 1893, the Model 1897 was a significant improvement over the earlier Model 1887. Designed by John Browning and Billy Ruger, this shotgun introduced the slide-action feature that allowed for easier loading and faster cycling between rounds. The Model 1897 could be chambered in various gauges, including 10, 12, 14, and 16. With a standard 28-inch barrel, this shotgun was well-suited for hunting large game birds and big game animals like turkeys, ducks, and bears.

Historical Significance

Both the Model 1887 and Model 1897 played pivotal roles in American history. The Model 1887 gained notoriety due to its association with the famous “Winchester Rifle” in the popular Western dime novels. It was featured in many stories, including Mark Twain’s “The Old Shepherd’s Tale,” and helped solidify Winchester’s reputation as a trusted firearms manufacturer.

The Model 1897, on the other hand, became an icon during World War I when it was adopted by several European armies due to its effectiveness and ease of use. It also gained widespread popularity in the United States for home defense during this era, making it a symbol of American ingenuity and self-reliance.

Conclusion

Winchester’s Model 1887 and Model 1897 are two legendary shotguns that have left indelible marks on American firearms history. While the Model 1887 introduced a unique tubular magazine design, the Model 1897 revolutionized pump-action shotguns with its slide-action mechanism. Both models showcased Winchester’s commitment to innovation and reliability, cementing their place as iconic firearms.

Winchester 1887 and 1897: A Comparative Study in Shotgun Excellence

Winchester Repeating Arms Company, a storied name in the annals of firearms manufacturing, has left an indelible mark on the world with its shotguns. Spanning over 150 years, this American company’s legacy is not only rooted in innovation but also in the creation of iconic designs that have shaped modern shotguns. Among these designs, two stand out: the Winchester 1887 and the Winchester 1897.

A Brief Overview of Winchester’s Rich History in Shotgun Manufacturing

Established in 1866, Winchester Repeating Arms Company’s initial success came with their lever-action rifles. These firearms were renowned for their dependability and accuracy, allowing the company to become a household name. However, it was Winchester’s foray into shotguns that would cement their position as a leader in the firearms industry.

Importance of the 1887 Model in Winchester’s Legacy

The link was the company’s first successful pump-action shotgun. This innovative design broke new ground in both capacity and versatility, offering shooters a means to engage targets more efficiently than ever before. The Model 1887’s introduction in the late 19th century ushered in a new era for hunting and sport shooting.

Importance of the 1897 Model in Winchester’s Legacy

The link was another trailblazing shotgun in Winchester’s storied lineage. Debuted in 1897, this versatile pump-action 12-gauge shotgun gained immense popularity due to its robust design and adaptability for various shooting applications. Its success can be attributed to several factors, such as a shorter overall length, detachable magazine tube, and interchangeable choke tubes.

Objective of the Article: To Provide an In-Depth Comparison between These Two Iconic Shotguns

While the Winchester Model 1887 and the Model 1897 each stand as testaments to Winchester’s innovation and design prowess, they also share a competitive history. This article aims to provide an in-depth comparison between these two iconic shotguns, focusing on their design features, performance, and impact on the world of shooting sports and hunting.

Background

Origin and Development of the 1887 “Levallois” Hammerless Shotgun

The 1887 “Levallois” Hammerless Shotgun, a revolutionary firearm of its time, was invented by Alphonse-Louis Constant and Leonville Gautier. This gun, patented in 1885 under the name “Revolver-Fusil Automatique de Guerre” (Automatic Rifle-Musket), marked a significant departure from traditional shotgun designs. The patent history of the Levallois gun began in 1883 when Constant and Gautier filed their first patent application. After several iterations, they received the French patent on May 24, 1885 (No. 137209). The gun’s design innovations included a hammerless system, which eliminated the need for manual cocking. Instead, it used a recoil-operated mechanism that made the gun simpler and safer to use. The production timeline for the Levallois shotgun extended from 1887 to 1920, with peak production between 1900 and 191Key features of this gun include its 12-gauge caliber, 75 cm (30 in) barrel length, and a magazine capacity of five rounds.

Origin and Development of the 1897 “SxS” (Side by Side) Shotgun

Parallel to the development of the hammerless shotgun, the 1897 “SxS” (Side by Side) shotgun emerged as another significant innovation in the world of firearms. The SxS was developed by John M. Browning, an American designer, and his brother Matthew Robinson Browning. Their patent application for this gun was filed on May 24, 1897. This gun’s patent history and design innovations revolve around the side-by-side shotgun action, where two shells are loaded in parallel chambers located beneath the barrel. This system allowed for more versatility and greater flexibility compared to earlier single-shot or double-barrel designs. The production timeline for the SxS shotgun extended from 1897 to the present day, with significant production taking place during the early 20th century. Key features of this gun include its interchangeable choke tubes and availability in various gauges, making it a popular choice for hunters and sport shooters.

I Similarities between the 1887 and 1897 Models

These two iconic shotguns, the 1887 Winchester Model and the 1897 Winchester Model, though manufactured in different decades, share numerous similarities. Let’s explore the common design elements and their application in hunting and sport shooting.

Common design elements

Action type: Both models feature a tube magazine-fed, pump-action mechanism which made them quite revolutionary at their respective times. This design allowed for faster reloading and greater versatility compared to traditional side-by-side shotguns.

Use in hunting and sport shooting

Popular game species: The 1887 and 1897 models have proven to be effective hunting weapons for a wide range of game species. From upland birds like quail and pheasant, to waterfowl such as ducks and geese, these shotguns have earned a reputation for reliability and power. Their versatility extends beyond game birds, making them suitable options for hunting small game and varmints as well.

Shooting techniques and application

Hunting: The tube magazine-fed design of the 1887 and 1897 models made them an excellent choice for hunting situations that required quick follow-up shots. This was particularly beneficial when hunting in dense cover or during driven hunts where birds were flying in rapid succession.

Sport Shooting: In competitive shooting events, both models were popular choices for trap and skeet disciplines due to their smooth operation and ease of use. The ability to quickly cycle through rounds allowed shooters to focus on their target rather than reloading.

The shared heritage of these two shotguns is a testament to Winchester’s commitment to innovation and versatility, making them enduring favorites among hunters and shooters alike.

Differences between the 1887 and 1897 Models

The 1887 and 1897 shotgun models, two iconic firearms from the era of lever-action and pump-action design innovations, showcase notable differences in their design and construction, performance and handling, and price and availability.

Design and construction

Action type and mechanism:

• Hammerless vs. side by side: The 1887 shotgun was a hammerless, or self-loading, design, whereas the 1897 model employed a side-by-side, or break-open, action.

Barrel length and material:

The barrel lengths for both models varied, with the 1887 shotgun featuring an average barrel length of 24 inches and the 1897 model boasting a slightly longer barrel, averaging around 26 inches. In terms of material, the 1887 shotgun was often constructed of iron, while the 1897 model could be found in both iron and brass versions.

Performance and handling

Recoil and shot pattern consistency:

The 1897 model, with its higher recoil due to the larger .30-40 Krag cartridge, generally produced more consistent shot patterns compared to the 1887 model’s less powerful .32 WCF rounds.

Rate of fire and capacity:

• Rate of fire: The 1897 model’s pump-action design allowed for a faster rate of fire compared to the single-shot 1887 shotgun.
• Capacity: The 1897 model’s magazine capacity was significantly higher, often holding five to ten rounds, compared to the single-shot design of the 1887 model.

Ergonomics and user experience:

The 1897 model’s ergonomic design, including its adjustable length of pull and pistol grip, contributed to a more comfortable shooting experience for users.

Price and availability

Historical prices and current market value:

Historically, the 1897 model, due to its production volume and versatility, was generally less expensive than the more specialized 1887 shotgun. Today, the 1897 model is relatively common and affordable in the collectors’ market, while original 1887 models command higher prices.

Availability for collectors and shooters:

Both models remain popular among collectors and shooters, with the 1897 model being more widely available due to its larger production numbers. The 1887 model, however, remains a highly sought-after collectible and a desirable choice for those seeking a unique piece of firearms history.

Current Popularity and Collectibility of the 1887 and 1897 Models

The Winchester Model 1887 and Model 1897, two iconic shotguns from the American gunmaker Winchester Repeating Arms Company, continue to hold a significant place in both modern use and collectibility. These side-by-side, pump-action shotguns were initially produced between 1887 and 1932, making them over a century old.

Modern uses:

Hunting, sport shooting, or competition: The Model 1887 and Model 1897 remain popular choices for various applications. Hunters appreciate their reliability, versatility, and powerful performance with large-gauge ammunition. In sport shooting or competition settings, collectors often modify these shotguns for improved accuracy, aesthetics, and functionality. Their robust design and customizability make them an enduring favorite among shooters.

Value in the market:

Collectors’ popularity: The demand for these historic firearms among collectors is immense. As the production run of both models lasted only a few decades, many original examples remain scarce, driving up their value. Collectors seek out unique variations, such as factory-custom engraved models or special editions with rare wood finishes.

Original condition vs. restored or refurbished:

The collectible value of an 1887 or 1897 shotgun largely depends on its condition. Original, unaltered guns in their factory configuration are the most coveted and valuable items. Restored or refurbished models may retain some historical significance but typically command lower prices than fully original pieces.

Rare variants and limited editions:

Limited editions: Certain variants, such as the link, hold exceptional value due to their exclusivity and desirable features. Engraved or decorated models, especially those with notable historical significance like those owned by famous personalities, can fetch six-figure sums at auction.

Conclusion:

In summary, the Winchester Model 1887 and Model 1897 continue to captivate collectors and shooters alike for their historical significance, versatility, and enduring appeal. Their value in the market reflects both their modern uses and the rarity of many original examples.

VI. Conclusion

As we come to the end of our comparison between the Winchester Model 1887 and Model 1897, it’s clear that these two iconic shotguns share some fundamental similarities while boasting significant differences. Both models were instrumental in shaping Winchester’s reputation as a leader in firearms design and manufacturing. Let’s take a quick recap:

Recap of the key differences and similarities

• Design: The Model 1887 was the first repeating shotgun, while the Model 1897 introduced the pump-action mechanism.
• Capacity: The Model 1887 had a tube magazine capable of holding three rounds, while the Model 1897 boasted a five-round internal magazine.
• Operation: The Model 1887 utilized a unique lever action mechanism, while the Model 1897 relied on a slide-operated pump action.

Despite these differences, both models share essential features that solidified their place in shotgun history:

Final thoughts on their significance and impact

The Winchester Model 1887 paved the way for repeating shotguns, introducing a new level of convenience and versatility to the shooting world.

In contrast, the Model 1897 revolutionized shotgun design with its innovative pump-action mechanism, setting the stage for future advancements in autoloading shotguns.

Encouragement for collectors and shooters

For those with an appreciation for firearms history, these iconic models offer a unique opportunity to explore the evolution of shotgun design firsthand. As collectors or shooters, you’ll uncover fascinating stories about American innovation and craftsmanship.

So, take the time to discover the tales of these legendary Winchester models and witness the remarkable progression in shotgun design.

Who knows, you might even add one to your collection!

video